Elden Ring, FromSoftware's critically acclaimed masterpiece, boasts a wide variety of unique and devastating weapons. Among them, the Godslayer's Greatsword stands as one of the most visually striking and thematically compelling Colossal weapons in the game. Infused with the power of black flames and god-slaying lore, this weapon offers immense destructive power—but with a catch: its effectiveness varies wildly depending on whether you're engaging in PvE or PvP.

This article will break down the performance of the Godslayer's Greatsword in both PvE and PvP, examining its moveset, scaling, Ash of War, and how its attributes interact differently with the environment and human opponents.

What is the Godslayer's Greatsword?

The Godslayer's Greatsword is a Colossal Sword that requires significant Strength (20) and Dexterity (22) to wield, along with a moderate Faith (20) investment. It's a weapon that scales well with Strength and Faith, especially when fully upgraded, making it ideal for hybrid builds focused on black flame incantations and heavy melee damage.

Its unique weapon skill, The Queen's Black Flame, unleashes a spinning slash imbued with black flame, followed by a heavy finishing strike that can melt enemies and apply percentage-based damage over time.

PvE: A Monster-Slaying Juggernaut

In PvE (Player vs. Environment), the Godslayer's Greatsword is one of the most reliable Colossal Swords in the game. Its combination of high raw damage, innate percentage-based burn from black flame, and long reach makes it especially effective against bosses and elite enemies.

1. High Burst Damage

The Queen's Black Flame skill dishes out massive AoE damage, and its burning effect lingers, chipping away at enemies' health even after the initial blow. This is particularly potent against high-HP bosses, where the tick damage translates into thousands of points over time.

2. Armor Shredding

Thanks to the black flame effect, which does damage based on a percentage of the enemy's max HP, this weapon is especially effective against bulky bosses like Godrick, Morgott, or the Fire Giant. These encounters are typically long and drawn out, and the DoT (damage over time) helps end them faster.

3. Safe Trading

The Colossal Sword class has natural poise damage and stagger potential. Combined with black flame burn, players can often interrupt or tank through enemy attacks during animations. In PvE, where enemy AI is predictable, the long wind-ups are easier to time, giving you a window to unleash heavy blows safely.

4. Scaling and Versatility

Faith scaling allows synergy with Black Flame Incantations like Scouring Black Flame or Black Flame Ritual, enabling thematic and powerful builds that combine spell and melee.

PvP: A Mixed Bag of Power and Limitations

While the Godslayer's Greatsword is a monster in PvE, it doesn't translate seamlessly into PvP. The same traits that make it dominant against AI-controlled enemies often become liabilities against skilled human opponents.

1. Punishable Animations

The Queen's Black Flame Ash of War has a long wind-up and recovery time. In PvP, experienced players can easily roll through the spinning slash and punish you during or after the attack. Its tracking is limited, and the second part of the animation is easily avoidable.

2. Predictability and Roll-Catching Issues

Colossal weapons have generally slow attack animations, which are easy to dodge. While the Godslayer's Greatsword has decent range, its lack of mix-up options means seasoned duelists can predict and roll through your swings. It's difficult to effectively roll-catch or pressure with speed.

3. Scaling Doesn't Help as Much

In PvP, the percentage-based damage of black flame is far less useful. Human players have lower max HP pools than bosses, and burn effects can be mitigated by healing or simply spacing out. This nullifies one of the weapon's biggest strengths.

4. Faith Hybrid Limitation

In PvP, hybrid builds have to make sacrifices—either you drop Vigor or Endurance, or you don't hit key softcaps for Strength or Faith. This results in lower survivability or decreased burst damage, especially when compared to meta PvP weapons like curved swords, halberds, or powerstanced rapiers.

5. Niche Use in PvP

That said, the weapon can still work in invasions or free-for-alls where chaos and multiple opponents distract from your telegraphed attacks. It also has niche intimidation value, as newer players tend to panic when they see flashy Ashes of War.

How to Optimize the Godslayer's Greatsword

If you're planning to run a build around this weapon, here's how to maximize its potential:

PvE Build Tips:

Stats: Focus on 50 Strength, 25 Faith, and enough Endurance to wear medium armor while maintaining mobility.

Talismans: Fire Scorpion Charm, Shard of Alexander (boosts Ash of War), and Godfrey Icon.

Incantation Synergy: Use Black Flame, Flame, Grant Me Strength, and Blessing of the Erdtree to buff damage and healing.

Armor: Equip something poise-heavy, like Bull-Goat or Maliketh's Set, to trade safely.

PvP Build Tips:

Stats: Prioritize 60 Vigor, moderate Strength (30–40), and Faith around 20–25 for scaling and utility.

Talismans: Claw Talisman (for jump attacks), Erdtree's Favor (HP/stamina boost), and Green Turtle Talisman (stamina regen).

Playstyle: Mix basic R1s with jump attacks and roll-catch attempts. Use Ash of War sparingly as a mix-up or punish tool when opponent overextends.

Conclusion: A PvE Titan, A PvP Gamble

The Godslayer's Greatsword is a perfect example of the PvE/PvP weapon divide in Elden Ring. It thrives in boss fights and PvE exploration with its devastating black flame skill and massive damage output, but its shortcomings are exposed in the faster, more reactive PvP arena.

If you love cinematic, high-risk, high-reward weapons with thematic flair, the Godslayer's Greatsword offers an incredible experience in PvE. But if your focus is on competitive PvP, it may be wiser to keep this blade as a secondary or stylistic choice, and opt for faster or more unpredictable weapons in duels.

Follow MMOexp, you'll be able to enjoy your Elden Ring adventure without the tedium and frustration, we provide the best Elden Ring Runes and Elden Ring Items 24/7 online. Freeing up your time to focus on the most rewarding aspects of the game.